first aired December 8, 2008
"The guys decide to take the girls out for a night on the town for some drinks. When a random guy hits on one of Chance's girls, he becomes irritated. A fight breaks out moments later between the brothers and the fellow, and Real breaks a bottle over the man's head. Chaos ensues, and the girls are escorted out of the bar. Nervous and crying, the girls arrive back at the house to find police officers waiting there to question them. One at a time, the girls are interrogated, but who will hold up under questioning and who will sell their man down the river?"
* Challenge Winners: Risky, Bay Bay Bay
* Bottom Two: Bay Bay Bay, K.O.
* Eliminated: K.O.
* Chance's Girls: Rabbit, Cali, Risky
* Real's Girls: Corn Fed, Bay Bay Bay, Milf