First aired March 15, 2009
Secrets come out when Bret invites his ex-girlfriend Ambre and Rock of Love alum Heather to interrogate the remaining six girl's exes. One of the girls becomes strangely upset when her ex-husband fails to show. Meanwhile, other girls question whether their hearts are in the right place. When Heather puts on the pressure in the interrogation room, fists and spittle fly.
—VH1 Episode Summary[38]
* City: St. Augustine, Florida
* Guests: Ambre Lake and Heather Chadwell
* Challenge: Ex Interrogation
* Bottom 3: Beverly, Brittanya, Ashley
* Eliminated: Brittanya, Ashley