First aired March 22, 2009
Four girls are challenged to write lyrics to one of Bret's songs and sing with him. One girl's friendship might ruin her chances with Bret, and another just might be too big of a fan. In the end, Bret must decide who he feels in harmony with, and who he needs to cut from the tour.
—VH1 Episode Summary[41]
* City: Orlando, Florida
* Challenge: Singing Performing
* Challenge Winner: Taya, Beverly
* Bottom Two: Mindy, Beverly
* Eliminated: Beverly